!
EXECUTION ALERT: OKLAHOMA
James “Jim” Pavatt
Thursday, November 12, 2026, 10:00 a.m. CT
Oklahoma State Penitentiary, McAlester
Method: Lethal injection
Tomorrow morning, one day after Veterans Day, the State of Oklahoma intends to execute James Pavatt, a 72-year-old U.S. Air Force veteran with nearly 22 years of service. He has maintained his innocence for 25 years. If the execution proceeds, it will be Oklahoma’s fourth of 2026. Only Governor Kevin Stitt can stop it now.
The Crime
On November 20, 2001, Rob Andrew, a 39-year-old Oklahoma City advertising executive, was shot and killed in the garage of the home he once shared with his estranged wife, Brenda Andrew, when he came to pick up their children. Pavatt, a friend of Rob’s, was having an affair with Brenda. Prosecutors said the two plotted the killing to collect an $800,000 life insurance policy. Before the funeral, Pavatt and Brenda Andrew fled to Mexico with her children and were caught months later. Both were sentenced to death.
Rob Andrew was a father picking up his kids. His family has carried this for a quarter century, and nothing in this alert diminishes that.
Who Pulled the Trigger?
Pavatt admits the affair and the flight to Mexico. He denies the killing. At his October clemency hearing he told the board he was not guilty of Rob’s murder and not guilty of shooting Brenda, who was wounded that night. He did not testify at his 2003 trial.
- No direct proof he was the shooter. His federal defenders argue there is no credible evidence placing him in that garage. At clemency, prosecutors argued that either Pavatt or Brenda Andrew could have fired the shots, but that both conspired.
- The bullet testimony. His attorney, Assistant Federal Defender Hunter Labovitz, told the board that both trial prosecutors told the jury the bullets matched, which suggested Pavatt was at the scene, when the prosecution knew the opposite was true.
- His co-defendant’s case was reopened. In 2025, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in Brenda Andrew’s favor and sent her case back for a new look at whether prejudicial evidence about her sex life made her trial fundamentally unfair. Her case is still on appeal. His defense argues her case is central to his.
Where Things Stand Now
- August 27, 2026: The Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals set the November 12 date.
- October 14: The Pardon and Parole Board voted 3-2 against clemency. Members Susan Stava and Robert Reavis II voted for mercy. Nearly 100 military veterans, through the group Leaving No One Behind, signed a letter urging clemency based on his service.
- Now: Attorney General Gentner Drummond has pushed for the execution to go forward. The final decision rests with Governor Stitt.
The Bigger Picture
A clemency vote this close, a co-defendant whose trial the highest court in the country found troubling, and a state that cannot say which of two people fired the gun: these are exactly the conditions under which an irreversible punishment should give everyone pause. The day after the nation thanked its veterans, Oklahoma plans to execute one whose guilt as the shooter has never been proven.
Sources: KOCO; KFOR; The Oklahoman; Oklahoma Voice; McAlester News-Capital; In Depth with Deon; KTUL.
Leave a Reply